India’s Test squad is in the midst of a key transition, and the battle for the No. 3 spot has sparked widespread debate following the retirement of Virat Kohli. Youngster Sai Sudharsan has emerged as a frontrunner for the pivotal batting position, earning praise from former cricketers and selectors alike. However, the omission of experienced campaigner Karun Nair has raised eyebrows, especially given his recent domestic form.
Nair, who once etched his name in the history books with a triple century in a Test match against England, has not been able to regain his place in the national side despite a strong domestic season. Many feel his experience and composure under pressure would have been invaluable in England’s testing conditions. Yet, the team management appears to be looking toward the future, with Sudharsan seen as part of India’s long-term plans.
Sudharsan’s performances over the past year have made a compelling case. He scored consistently in both red-ball and white-ball formats, showing a temperament that suggests he could handle the demands of batting at No. 3 in English conditions. While Karun Nair had a stellar run in the Ranji Trophy, selectors are seemingly prioritizing youth and current momentum over past accomplishments.
What makes the decision even more surprising is the experience gap left by Kohli’s absence. A player like Nair, with prior Test experience and a history of producing big scores under pressure, seemed a natural fit to stabilize the top order. But by backing Sudharsan, India appears to be betting on a player who has yet to be tested at the highest level in overseas conditions — a move that could either pay off spectacularly or backfire.
Nair’s exclusion has once again highlighted the unpredictable nature of selection policies in Indian cricket. Though he continues to perform at the domestic level, breaking into the Test XI remains a challenge with the selectors favoring new faces. Despite his obvious hunger and fitness, Karun Nair finds himself watching from the sidelines while younger players are given the nod.
Looking ahead to the England series, the pressure on Sudharsan will be immense. Expectations are high for whoever occupies the No. 3 slot, especially in a five-match series in challenging English conditions. While fans and analysts debate the merits of Nair versus Sudharsan, the team management has clearly signaled a shift toward investing in the next generation of Indian batters.
In the end, the decision to snub Karun Nair may not just be about form, but a reflection of the team’s broader strategy to transition into a new era. For Nair, the message is clear — continued performances may not be enough; timing and team direction matter just as much.