As England prepare for the decisive fifth Test against India at The Oval, former fast bowler Stuart Broad and ex-captain Nasser Hussain have both called for caution over Jofra Archer’s inclusion, warning that his heavy bowling workload could lead to fatigue or re-injury.
Broad, speaking on the back of England’s drawn fourth Test at Old Trafford, noted that Archer has delivered significant spells since his return from a lengthy injury layoff. He argued that the management must avoid overusing him so soon, especially with the Ashes tour looming. “You can’t bowl a pacer of Archer’s pace into the ground. England need him fit not just for one Test but for the years ahead,” Broad stated, urging selectors to consider rotation and hand Gus Atkinson or another seamer an opportunity.
Hussain echoed similar concerns, highlighting that Archer’s comeback after years away from Test cricket has been physically demanding. He had earlier described Archer’s early selection in the second Test as a “gamble,” suggesting the bowler needed more gradual exposure through county cricket before enduring the intensity of back-to-back Tests. According to Hussain, while Archer’s quality is undeniable, his return must be managed with long-term fitness in mind rather than short-term gain.
Archer’s recent performances underline why the debate is so prominent. He claimed a five-wicket haul in the third Test at Lord’s and backed it up with another strong showing in Manchester. However, his history of elbow and back injuries means even successful outings come with an element of risk if recovery windows are too short.
The final Test presents a selection dilemma for England. With the series still in the balance and Archer eager to play, the temptation to field him is strong. Yet, the demands of four high-intensity matches and limited rest have raised red flags. Broad believes England should prioritize his long-term role, especially with the Ashes and other major series ahead.
Head coach Brendon McCullum has previously spoken of carefully managing Archer’s workload, and this latest debate adds further pressure on the selection committee to weigh the immediate importance of the Oval Test against the fast bowler’s future.
As the team announcement approaches, England must strike a balance between chasing victory and safeguarding one of their most valuable assets. For Broad and Hussain, the message is clear: resting Archer now could pay off far more than risking him in the short term.