Former Pakistan fast bowler Shoaib Akhtar did not hold back in his post-match comments following Pakistan’s Super Four defeat to India in the 2025 Asia Cup. Akhtar launched a scathing attack on captain Salman Ali Agha, questioning his leadership and raising broader concerns about the Pakistan Cricket Board’s (PCB) decisions regarding team management and strategy.
In his televised remarks, Akhtar described the team’s performance as disappointing and attributed the loss to leadership deficiencies rather than just on-field execution. “We are weak, and it is not our loss,” he remarked, highlighting what he sees as systemic problems in Pakistan’s cricket administration and the lack of strong captaincy to guide a talented side. This comment sparked widespread debate among cricket analysts, former players, and fans, with opinions divided on whether it was an unfair critique or a candid observation about Pakistan’s challenges.
Akhtar specifically criticized Agha’s tactical decisions during the match, including bowling changes and batting order management. He argued that the team’s failure to capitalize on key moments was symptomatic of a captain who lacked decisiveness under pressure. Analysts have noted that Pakistan’s batting collapse in the middle overs and inability to accelerate the chase effectively were critical factors in India’s six-wicket victory. Akhtar framed these shortcomings as consequences of leadership lapses rather than individual player errors alone.
The former pacer also extended his critique to the PCB, questioning the board’s choices in appointing leadership and assembling the squad. According to Akhtar, the combination of inexperienced leadership and administrative mismanagement has left the team vulnerable in high-pressure matches, particularly against top-tier opponents like India. His comments have reignited discussions about governance, selection policies, and the need for stronger leadership in Pakistan cricket.
Salman Ali Agha, meanwhile, has maintained a professional stance, emphasizing that the team will focus on learning from the defeat and preparing for upcoming Super Four fixtures. PCB officials have not publicly responded to Akhtar’s remarks, though insiders suggest internal discussions are underway to assess captaincy performance and team morale after the loss.
The controversy has generated significant media attention, highlighting the tension between former players’ outspoken opinions and current team dynamics. Akhtar’s remarks, while harsh, reflect a broader sentiment among some cricket followers that Pakistan must address leadership and strategic shortcomings to remain competitive in international tournaments.
With Pakistan now needing strong performances in their remaining Super Four matches to secure a place in the Asia Cup final, the pressure on Agha and the team is mounting. How they respond—both on and off the field—will be closely watched by fans, analysts, and former players alike. Akhtar’s criticism may serve as a wake-up call or could add to the pressure on the young captain and his squad as they navigate the high-stakes stage of the tournament.
12BET Shortlisted for Sportsbook Operator of the Year at SBC Awards 2025