After Pakistan’s disappointing defeat to India in the Asia Cup 2025, former fast bowler Mohammad Amir has delivered a fiery response to what he sees as excessive and agenda-driven criticism from ex-players and pundits. He argued that many of these critics had been waiting for a poor performance to jump on the team, and he urged fans to support the squad during this transition phase instead of piling on negativity.
Pakistan were bowled out for just 127 against India in a high-voltage clash, a total that India chased down with ease to secure a seven-wicket win. The batting collapse of key players such as Salman Ali Agha and Saim Ayub triggered a barrage of criticism, with former cricketers and media analysts questioning the team’s selections, approach, and even leadership direction. Amir, however, believes the backlash has been disproportionate.
Taking to social media, Amir lashed out at what he called agenda-driven narratives. He said that critics have been waiting for a single bad game from Pakistan’s young players to unleash harsh commentary, which he feels is unfair. He reminded everyone that Pakistan is currently undergoing a transition, with younger players being tested on the big stage, and that failures are part of that process. According to him, condemning them after just one loss risks damaging confidence at a crucial time.
Amir further emphasized that criticism should be constructive, not destructive. Rather than targeting individual players, he urged analysts and former players to focus on solutions—whether that means addressing Pakistan’s tendency to collapse under pressure, shoring up the middle order, or preparing players for high-stakes matches mentally. He said that negative commentary only adds to the burden of already pressured cricketers who know they have let fans down.
His comments have sparked a mixed response. Some fans agree with Amir, saying the team needs backing to come out stronger in upcoming fixtures, particularly with key games left in the Asia Cup. Others argue that criticism is inevitable and even necessary when Pakistan performs below expectations, especially in a match against India where stakes are sky-high.
Amir’s intervention also highlights a broader debate about how former players and experts shape public opinion. Their strong words can motivate, but they can also crush morale if overly harsh. The former pacer stressed that Pakistan’s youngsters need space to grow and should not be compared with experienced seniors who have had years to prove themselves.
Ultimately, Amir’s message is about perspective. He acknowledged that Pakistan’s loss was disappointing but warned against turning one bad outing into a full-blown crisis. With more games to play and a chance to bounce back, he believes unity and encouragement are more important than finger-pointing. As Pakistan prepares for its next clash, the spotlight will not only be on the players but also on whether the public and pundits take Amir’s advice and stand behind their team instead of tearing it down.
12BET Shortlisted for Sportsbook Operator of the Year at SBC Awards 2025