Sydney Sixers’ push for another Big Bash League (BBL) title has taken a tense turn, with growing pressure on the franchise to drop Babar Azam amid criticism that his contribution has not matched expectations. What began as a marquee overseas signing designed to add class and stability has instead turned into a selection dilemma at the most critical stage of the season.
Babar arrived in the BBL with enormous reputation. One of the most technically accomplished batters of the modern era, his signing was viewed as a statement of intent by the Sixers. The expectation was clear: consistency at the top, calm under pressure, and match-winning innings in knockout situations. So far, that return has been underwhelming.
Critics have focused less on raw numbers and more on impact. In a tournament that increasingly rewards explosive starts and rapid momentum shifts, Babar’s traditional anchoring approach has struggled to keep pace. While he has shown glimpses of class, too many innings have stalled during the powerplay or failed to accelerate when the game demanded urgency.
The timing could not be worse for the Sixers. With the title race tightening and margins razor-thin, every selection decision is magnified. Opposing teams have targeted the Sixers’ top order aggressively, knowing that slow starts place immediate pressure on the middle and lower order to compensate.
Former players and analysts have openly questioned whether Babar’s style suits the BBL’s high-tempo demands, particularly on Australian pitches that reward clean hitting and calculated risk. The criticism is not about talent — that is undisputed — but about tactical fit.
There is also the overseas-player equation to consider. Every overseas slot must deliver clear value. With other international players across the league producing match-defining cameos, patience is wearing thin when output does not translate into wins. For a franchise chasing trophies rather than brand value, sentiment carries little weight.
Inside the Sixers’ camp, the debate is believed to be intense. Dropping a player of Babar’s stature is not a decision taken lightly. It risks headlines, backlash, and second-guessing — especially if replacements fail to deliver. But sticking with an underperforming option purely on reputation can be equally damaging.
Supporters are split. Some argue that big-game experience and calmness are priceless in finals cricket, and that one defining innings could flip the narrative overnight. Others counter that the Sixers cannot afford to wait for form to arrive while rivals surge ahead.
The broader context matters too. Babar has faced criticism in multiple T20 leagues for similar reasons — strong averages but limited strike-rate impact. The BBL, with its short boundaries and relentless pace, magnifies that scrutiny even further.
For the Sixers, the decision now is brutally simple: trust pedigree or chase momentum. Finals cricket rewards clarity and bold calls. Whether that means backing Babar for one last chance or making the ruthless call to move on will define their title run.
12BET Shortlisted for Sportsbook Operator of the Year at SBC Awards 2025