The International Cricket Council (ICC) has confirmed that Andy Pycroft will again serve as match referee for the upcoming Asia Cup 2025 Super Four clash between India and Pakistan, a decision that has stirred fresh debate given the Pakistan Cricket Board’s formal protest over his role in the earlier group stage match.
The controversy stems from the so-called “handshake row” that unfolded during the India-Pakistan group game. Reports suggested that Pycroft had instructed both captains to skip the customary post-match handshake due to tensions, which Pakistan argued went against the spirit of the game and violated protocols. The PCB subsequently filed an official complaint, seeking Pycroft’s removal from officiating duties in any further games involving their team.
Adding fuel to the fire was the Players and Match Officials Area (PMOA) dispute, where Pakistan allegedly filmed a conversation with Pycroft in a restricted zone — a move that itself could lead to disciplinary review by the ICC. The PCB defended its actions as necessary documentation, but the ICC viewed it as a breach of PMOA regulations, setting up a confrontation between the board and the governing body.
Despite these tensions, the ICC chose continuity, citing a lack of formal breach by Pycroft that would warrant replacing him. Their stance underscores a message that match officials cannot be replaced on demand due to team dissatisfaction, as this could set a precedent undermining neutrality and authority.
Pakistan’s response has been predictably strong. Reports indicate the team management has canceled pre-match media briefings to avoid inflaming the situation further. Former players and analysts have also weighed in, some siding with PCB’s concerns over match protocol, while others argue that the focus should return to cricket and let the ICC’s internal review process play out quietly.
The decision to retain Pycroft puts additional spotlight on the upcoming fixture, which was already one of the most anticipated contests of the tournament. Every decision, from toss to close calls on the field, is likely to face intense scrutiny from players, fans, and broadcasters.
For India, the development has little direct impact, but the team will be keen to keep distractions minimal and maintain their unbeaten run. Pakistan, on the other hand, may look to channel their sense of grievance into motivation on the field.
Ultimately, the ICC’s decision signals a firm stance on protecting match official independence, even if it risks further confrontation with a major board. The India-Pakistan Super Four clash now carries not just competitive stakes but also symbolic weight — a test of how the sport manages fairness, governance, and optics under global attention.
12BET Shortlisted for Sportsbook Operator of the Year at SBC Awards 2025