Sanju Samson has turned the Kerala Cricket League into his personal stage, producing a string of match-winning knocks that have set off a fresh debate in Indian cricket. His form has been so dominant that it has forced selectors, the captain, and even fans into a tough question: should Samson open the batting for India in the upcoming Asia Cup, or does Shubman Gill’s stature as vice-captain make him untouchable?
For the Kochi Blue Tigers, Samson has been unstoppable. He has blasted 368 runs in five innings at a strike rate close to 187, including scores of 121 off 51 balls, 89 off 46, 62 off 37, and 83 off 41. These weren’t just flashy cameos—each innings shifted matches decisively. The sheer volume of boundaries, including nearly 30 sixes in the tournament, has underlined his fearless batting. Samson, once seen as inconsistent, has suddenly transformed into a run machine at the top of the order.
Timing is everything in cricket, and Samson’s red-hot streak comes just as India prepare for the Asia Cup in the UAE. The problem for him is that Gill, India’s Test captain and newly reinstated T20 vice-captain, has also been slotted as an opener. That leadership role makes him extremely difficult to dislodge, regardless of form. For the selectors, this creates a classic dilemma: reward Samson’s explosive form or stick with Gill’s status and long-term value.
Many former players have weighed in. Ajinkya Rahane has openly admitted that Samson deserves a spot but expects Gill and Abhishek Sharma to open instead. Analysts like Mohammad Kaif have suggested that Samson’s inclusion is anything but guaranteed, pointing out that his earlier opportunities often came only when Gill was unavailable. Chief selector Ajit Agarkar has also implied that Gill is the preferred choice, leaving Samson fighting for relevance despite his current heroics.
Samson’s case isn’t just about numbers; it’s about balance. India’s top order has often been criticized for being conservative in T20 cricket. Samson’s ability to go hard from ball one is exactly what modern white-ball sides demand. He offers the kind of impact that can take games away in the powerplay, something India has sometimes lacked. On the flip side, fitting both Gill and Samson into the XI isn’t straightforward. Samson could be pushed into the middle order, but he has struggled for consistency there in the past.
The dynamic also exposes a deeper issue in Indian cricket: do selectors value form over reputation? Gill’s leadership role suggests that the management is planning long-term around him. Yet, Samson’s performances in the KCL are too loud to ignore. Even head coach Gautam Gambhir and captain Suryakumar Yadav may be forced into rethinking their strategy, given the pressure to field an in-form, destructive opener.
As the Asia Cup looms, the opening slot has become India’s most hotly contested position. If Samson is rewarded for his blazing KCL form, it would mark a bold shift towards meritocracy and attacking cricket. If Gill holds the spot, it will show that hierarchy and leadership still carry more weight than immediate form. Either way, the first match of the Asia Cup will reveal more than just India’s opening pair—it will show where Indian cricket’s priorities truly lie.
12BET Shortlisted for Sportsbook Operator of the Year at SBC Awards 2025